Richard Coleman on Islamic heritage

It seems too late to offer help to the Saudi’s to find a balance between the need for a new, bigger Mosque and the need to maintain representative and worthy monuments of the past for prosperity, connection with the community’s roots and a sense of continuity. Time and again mankind has been shown to benefit from a memory of the past in seeking to enrich the future. Architecture is so often the prime symbolism of that memory.

Medina has a packed centre and the Mosque clearly belongs there. One can only hope that the proposition of creating the world’s biggest building, a new Mosque for 1.6 million Muslims, overlaying this central site, will be one which combines preservation and rejuvenation with the creation of the new. There are rumours that it will not. A fundamentalist approach is apparently being adopted which will cut ties with the past, to rid the city of its historic connections, even with the buildings that hold meaning as poignant as that which houses the tomb of the Prophet Mohamed.

I hope it’s not true. I hope it’s not too late to apply the kind of analysis that we use in the UK, where we accept occasionally that heritage must give way to the new, particularly where doing so serves the public good. It seems that a public good is afoot in this case, but is the argument balanced? Has the exercise of analysis been carried out? Have the 4 archi-types of cultural value, developed here, been applied there? First, how valuable is the archaeology of the buildings? Second, how valuable is the expression of the past and how valuable the craftsmanship of previous builders to display it? Third, what about the beauty of the structures under threat. Do they lift the spirit? Will the new building achieve the same value? Fourth, will the familiarity of the place be lost, that which people are comforted by, that which the community as a whole recognise as theirs.

These are of course western values and they may not be appropriate to the desserts of the Middle East.

If similar questions have been asked, out of the Muslim culture, then so be it. If not, perhaps a pause for thought, deep thought of the kind the Prophet Mohamed might have applied, should prevail before it is too late.

Richard Coleman
Heritage Consultant London
Chairman of World Architecture News WAN

Countdown: WAD 2013

October 6th, 2013

Comments

  1. Thank you Mr. Coleman for your very thoughtful article. The Saudis have absolutely no right to play God with holy architecture that has international acclaim. This is not about making the mosque bigger for more worshippers but having as many people shop in their dazzling malls and renting their luxurious hotels. The Prophet’s familiar Green Dome is the most uplifting sign of great comfort and peace for Muslims because under it rests the greatest spiritual leader humanity has seen (peace be upon him). Taking this away or relocating it will definitely not just violate religious rulings but also deeply offend and shatter spiritual sensibilities that have both vertical and horizontal dimensions in terms of historicity and geographic span respectively. Accommodating more worshippers is a lame excuse for lust for commercial expansion and promoting an agenda of flawed religious reasoning that very wrongfully confuses love with worship. What can we do to help save our heritage?

  2. this would we better if we consider all facts concerning the plan

    1 what mosques that r planned to be demolished?
    2 what kind of demolition: complete replacement or incorporated into the new building, just like the tomb?

    regards

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 46 other followers

%d bloggers like this: